Thursday, March 18, 2010

Case Study Three

Question 1 & 2


At its core interaction design can overcome “complacency of the artifact” by breaking away from commoditization. Jon Kolko discusses this commoditization as both digital and consumed artifacts becoming a means to an end. Interaction design can thus unshackle these connotations and begin to create an atmosphere of behavioral change and new connections with these artifacts. A relevant example we can explore is our own field of design. Design firms are not immune to commoditization in the eyes of the clients and companies we work for. AgencyNet developed their company website with these issues in mind http://www.agencynet.com/. AgencyNet takes their brand image of a hip design firm with a diverse group of talented employees and implements an interactive design to emotionally and personally connect you to those individuals. The brand feeds our expected experiences of not only the company but the ways we encounter them. By implementing the office building and allowing the user to see and experience the workplace we become part of the team which creates an important connection the clients seeks. The user can click and view twitter bubbles that follow particular employees around creating another personal connection to the people who make up this firm and not just the firm itself. In many ways the user experience is developing a narrative by humanizing the design firm beyond just a name and body of work. Through the interactive design the brand and artifact are strengthened beyond the idea of just a design firm that is just a means to an end for the client and positions interpersonal connections that draw in potential clients seeking something more than just another design firm.


Question 3


Interaction design and User-experience design create positive user experiences and consumer trust by involving the viewer in the brand. Narrative can be woven deeper into the minds of the consumer if they are part of the story or they feel involved in its development. Making consumers feel like they are part of the story of a company reaffirms their choice to use that particular company over another and will build brand loyalty and trust. The customer will continually turn to their brand of choice because they know the company has their best interest in mind and that their history is based around meeting those expectations. Nike exemplifies this idea not through interactive flash pieces or games and lots of clickableness, but its video’s and outreach to its customers (http://www.nike.com/nikeos/p/nike/en_US/). Watching the video on the main page establishes an emotional connection to an ideal Nike promotes and encourages individual betterment. We as the consumer experience this and overlaid on the video is a link to the company’s Facebook page which contains a motivational typography piece and a section for Nike community members to share motivational personal stories (http://www.facebook.com/justdoit?v=app_7146470109). Positive user experience is created because the user is enveloped in a narrative, can become part of that narrative and begin to relate Nike to something more than just a product. We want to trust Nike because they “get it.” They know that adversity is something that everyone encounters but that through perseverance we can prevail. It is a powerful connotation we have with the brand as a result because when we want to overcome athletic adversity we automatically remember Nike.


Question 4 & 5

Web interactions that listen, learn and modify user experiences promote brand development by personalizing an experience. Consumers want to feel a unique connection to brands and by “customizing” these experiences the brand can be developed and expanded. Customized experiences can gather information from the target demographic, learn then modify the experience to better address their needs. The brand’s positioning is then evolved to better suit it’s demographic and further develops that group’s loyalty. A brand should flow and creating a comfortable, intuitive, consistent and trustworthy experience plays to that aesthetic. User experience should never frustrate the viewer and the connotations that come with that frustration are never on the top list of a successful brand. If a user cannot trust a company to create an intuitive and consistent experience how can they trust the actual product or service being provided to them? https://www.amazon.com/gp/yourstore/home?ie=UTF8&ref_=topnav_ys Amazon is a great example of web interactions that listen, learn and modify the user experience and the influence they have on a brand. Amazon has developed a community of web shoppers whose personal opinions and buying trends are observed and used to modify each individuals shopping experience. Tracked information creates suggested new items to buy but also keeps the user current on potential new branches of products they might be interested in. By developing a community these sects of buyers can interact and have a share in the brand that is Amazon. Facebook recently has become a poor example of user experience. Facebook was created to be a resource for friends and communities to stay in touch. With constant layout redesigns new unneeded features added focus has been lost. To access the friends list, an aspect that the whole brand and purpose is built on, must now be accessed by going through not one, not two, but three steps. The brand actually feels as though its regressing and losing focus throwing the whole successful positioning the service was developed for, out the window. Web interactions should be interesting but there is something to be said for simplicity to achieve brand goals.

Case Study Two

What is the Starbucks brand?

The Starbucks brand has created a name that has become synonymous with “gourmet” high priced coffee. Everything from their stores to their furniture and color scheme that inhabit said stores is designed with the brand in mind.

How did Starbucks build such a successful brand?

To begin, instead of advertising they relied on word of mouth and storefront appeal to pass their brand along. They continued to refine their stores image as they expanded making sure that the brand recognition and identity stayed similar throughout every new store. They tried to keep their fingers on the social pulse by supporting things like recycling, music and so on. In addition they expanded individual customization (custom drinks) and brand experience.

What is Starbucks DSI?

Starbucks is the world’s leading retailer, roaster, and brand of specialty coffee with coffeehouses worldwide. First and foremost it always appears to be about the coffee but the atmosphere they create could arguably be and ideological DSI.

What role has design aesthetic played in the rise of Starbucks?

As the brand grew so did the design aesthetic. It evolved into a color pallete and design theme that would be recognizable throughout all of Starbucks products and even their stores. By keeping this consistency the brand created a feeling of safeness and a reliable comfort when you see a recognizable logo, color scheme, or storefront. It essentially was a backbone for brand loyalty.

How would you characterize Starbucks’ positioning? 


Starbucks’ positioning seems to be (now) target in too many directions. Their focus should always be on their product (the coffee) and atmosphere in their storefronts. Because they deviated into the markets of food, music, and supposedly Hollywood at one point, they are going to lose their DSI and claim to #1.

How would you summarize their product and market development strategies?

Create a wide variety of different coffee based beverages to suit a large taste of consumers and have them served in storefronts that are very recognizable and welcoming. Make these storefronts a ‘third place’ away from home and work and have recognizable logos and design schemes that are synonymous with our name.

Why has Starbucks encountered difficulties in recent years? 


Essentially Starbucks was too successful too quickly. They lost consumers who wanted a smaller coffee shop kind of feel and those who did not want over complicated menus and long lines. Add onto the fact that with down turns in the economy customers are less likely to spend four dollars a visit on coffee. In other places like Europe (and more recently in America) the brand has become stale and unchanged because every Starbucks visited is the same or extremely similar.

What recommendations would you make to Starbucks marketing executives to help them moving forward in terms of their use of design as brand?

As per the readings, I agree that their design could use a shock treatment in which they make their stores feel more like small town cafes. Maybe hire small local independent design firms to brand each store and site so that it reinforces this unique homegrown feeling. This might be costly but could payoff in the long run rather than continued loss of business and unnecessary storefront closures.

Case Study One

What does this product do for the company’s brand?


It will attempt to branch the Google brand name out into mobile web, mobile operating systems and mobile devices themselves. Essentially the brand will try to move out of the realm of just being the reliable democratic search engine everyone relies on and become something more. Depending on the result the product could have positive or negative impacts upon the brand itself.


What are the sources of Googles’ brand equity? 



Google is now synonymous with the idea of web search and it is also the source of their brand equity. To delve deeper Googles’ definition of itself as a democratic search engine plays a large role in the consumer level because they are seen as a company that will promote all sites equally based upon strict coding that sorts based on the user input. As a result consumers will connect more with the Google brand and constantly remember what they ‘stand’ for.


What are the strengths associated with Googles’ brand?

Reliability comes to the forefront as users trust the engine to give them unbiased results based on rating systems. Google consistently introduces new services for free that for the most part have been very popular and useful.


Describe some of the design challenges Googles’ Android faces in terms of its publicity, phone design, and marketing?


Publicity-wise, as with any brand, it is near impossible to promote every phone that runs the operating system and in addition call to attention the ever changing versions of the OS/apps that come with open source software. Add onto this the fact that every company outside of Apple will want to have a phone with this operating system and the three different plans Google has installed make their publicity sometimes unknown. For example one article mentions that some people who bought new phones had absolutely no idea that the Android system they had was from Google or if they did had no idea their particular phone did not come with the standard Google apps. This creates a nightmare for promoting all the different variations in one location or trying to create ads that help sell the OS overall. In the phone design department it will be hard to keep a consistent design in phones due to the ability of the software to run on almost any new phone from any company. Apple has the ability to only sell a limited variety of phones that use their OS and iPhone apps. Googles’ Android also faces compatibility issues should a phone not contain the newest hardware (they could run older versions but maybe not new and improved community versions). Google may have to rely on all the other companies to get creative with selling their versions of the phones with the OS attached. The marketing aspect mostly ties into what I’ve already mentioned above. It will be difficult for Google to be influential on the marketing of the OS themselves because they offer it to so many companies and in a multitude of versions.

How does the role of branding differ for consumer services vs. consumer products?


One big difference is the ability to create a memorable impression through influence of a brand logo. Services tend not to have a mobile logo on them and in this example Google can say ‘Google Android’ all they want but when people get their phone out it is a Verizon, Sony, HTC and so on. This would be why they are pushing companies to get a particular plan so that the Google logo can be put directly on the phones. When branding a service one must also consider it to be like branding an idea because most times it does not take a physical form. The brand has to work smarter and harder to sell something that is not physically there.


Evaluate Android in terms of its competitors. How well is it positioned? What are its points-of-parity and points-of difference?


I would put Android at about #2-4 or so compared to its largest competitors right now, Apple being #1. Right now Android is positioned a bit awkwardly because it does not have the market recognition of the iPhone right now and that it is spread out to a multitude of phones with no clear #1. With Androids research of the Apple OS before releasing itself many of the simplicity features are there (from the touch screen to the use of thousands of apps). The major points of difference come from the open source. New versions of the OS that users can download themselves allow for customization and the ability to use widgets, flash, and user developed features. Android is also in the hands of many different companies who can develop for the OS themselves which creates a larger chance that someone will strike gold with a feature not yet developed. While customization is an interesting topic Apple tends to lock that realm closed so Android has the whole market to try and change peoples’ perception of using a ‘Big Brother’ OS.


What recommendations would you make in order to maximize Android in relation to all of the other software and services Google provides?


First and foremost make sure that all those other software and services can be used on Android which would create a nice link to interchangeable reliability. One article mentions Google working on its own phone to maximize its retain ability of the Google name with Android which I believe is a smart move. Let the market taste the OS through other companies then release your own phone displaying the true power of the OS and it will create a larger interest in the phone based on the OS from the Google brand itself. Another step Google could take is start providing special features for their popular software and services that are particularly tailored to Android. Essentially using an already well known service to push a new feature on the OS you are trying to sell.


Who is Google’s consumer base? Does extending its brand bode well for the brand?


Googles’ consumer base is pretty much anyone who searches the web for information. They pick up more consumers from people who want their web mail, YouTube, calendars, and maps all congruently tied together or individual aspects. It is somewhat tough to see this far ahead because almost every move that Google has made in the free market realm has been a pretty huge success. For example Google Chrome which has a strong user base and is making waves next to Firefox as a new reliable web browser. If Google can make Android a success their up and coming PC operating system stands to change computing and would make Google into an incredible brand. But there is always the chance that they step to far out of their target markets and over extend themselves like Starbucks and other companies before them.

Critical Questions Set Five

After reading “Design is Advertising” I found that I fundamentally disagree with the author about not only the whole premise that design is advertising but his/her particular conclusion of design as a medium or means to an end to achieve advertising. Why not turn this idea on its head and consider the other side? Let us postulate that advertising is just a product of design. Designers seek out a problem and through design solve that problem. Creating successful advertisements that takes into account all of the branding and design issues that are carried with it supports this idea. Perhaps if we were considering designers as simply graphic artists this assertion would be somewhat true but even then there is purpose beyond advertising.

Today the brand is about unique differentiation and the promotion of the individual over the conglomerate. This change has occurred over a number of years and after reading the essay “Johnny Can’t Dissent” it left me with a lingering question in the back of my mind. Could we be on a circular path and one day return the ideals of a “community” focus that is less about the individual? In some ways we already are with the implementation of social and cultural movements such and recycling. We all still want to be unique in certain ways but long to be part of something bigger. Perhaps this idea is not so cut and dry as to assume that we seek “chaos” and a selfish individuality but that it takes time to feel out acceptable directions which in the long run will shape the very way brands, companies and their consumers meld.