Sunday, August 29, 2010

Tuesday, April 27, 2010

Case Study Four

Research and find examples that can help answer the following critical questions. Be prepared to discuss them in class:

1. What are archetypes and why are they important to branding AND design?

Archetypes are the basic human characteristics that can be found throughout the different levels of human conscious and subconscious. They are ever present in the stories, myths and influential individuals we find through history. According to Olivier Blanchard they, “tap deep into our motivations and sense of meaning.” There are twelve (potentially thirteen) archetypes; hero, magician, outlaw, jester, lover, everyman, caregiver, ruler, creator, innocent, sage, explorer and disciplined achiever (thirteenth proposed archetype). Archetypes become so important to branding and design because they establish a persona for the brand. With this persona the brand can flourish in a natural direction that will be identifiable with core values and connections that consumers are inherently familiar with. Designers can then use these traits defined by the chosen archetype to embody their created work with the company’s persona. They also add a key value of focus for the designed work so that each individual piece can reference the archetype and never stray off course.

2. What is the relationship between branding, personas, and archetypes? Gives specific examples of that illustrate these relationships.

Branding relies upon a strong persona to connotate and convey specific aspects of the brand to the consumer. The persona establishes an identity for the brand and gives it character. A choice of archetype which will determine what type of persona and eventually what type of brand the consumer will encounter. The articles that were read make note of Nike as a prime example of archetypes and branding. If we look at the core of Nike a hero archetype can be found which then develops the brand’s persona as a source for achieving the victory and goal oriented characteristics its consumers want to be labeled with. When people then think of Nike these associations and perceptions of a heroic brand that helps you succeed are the first images that come to mind.

3. How can archetype help to deal with the “intangible” elements of a brand such as contextual values, emotions, aspirations and projections? Give specific examples of where this is the case.

Archetypes help to deal with the “intangible” elements of brand by speaking to core “aspects of the human condition” which we are hardwired with us. These elements then, with the aid of the archetypes chosen, become part of the very identity of the brand. Consumers will seek these attributes from the brand projecting themselves upon it and eventually become a patron who will then want the brand’s archetype projected upon them. One example we can find of archetypes assisting intangible elements is Pandora (http://www.pandora.com/). Like Nike, Pandora utilizes the use of a Greek figure that personifies and fits into an archetype to establish the brand. Using this mythological figure ties caregiver, regular guy/gal, and explorer archetypes to Pandora’s brand. Pandora’s name itself implies “all giving” but also is associated with some mystery. That is what Pandora seeks by developing and internet radio service for its users in a market that saw a dramatic rise in “free” music with potential social consequences. People hear Pandora and pull these archetype values established by the character and associate them, despite them being intangible, with Pandora internet radio.

4. What is the relationship between brand core essence and brand archetype? Provide current branding examples of where the two are synonymous and explain why you believe this to be the case. Provide detailed examples for support.

Brand core essence should be derived from the brand archetypes chosen. Brand core essence defines what the brand is “about” and is at the very heart of where the rest of the brand is developed from. Archetypes are essentially the means by which the core essence is chosen and constructed because the elements defined in archetypes are molded and combined to define the true nature of the brand. Intel comes to mind when thinking of examples of brand core essence and brand archetype being synonymous with one another. Intel uses a magician archetype that transforms the consumer bases use of computers and also transports them to a world where Intel is bridging the gap between was is possible and impossible (at least in the consumer’s mind). We can look at Intel’s site (www.intel.com) and see that they constantly use the archetype to define their brand core essence. The catch phrase on the first page “Not just faster. Smarter.” embodies their archetype by taking us to a place where our technology not only evolves one aspect but can break the mold and become something more. At their core Intel has used this archetype for a while when previously they use “Intel inside” as their phrase of choice having their consumers envision that their processors were becoming like human brains. The core essence never derived from the attributes defined by the archetype and eventually they became synonymous with each other.

5. As you begin to develop Branding Project #5, how can archetypes and personas aid you in the development of your brand? What are some examples of how brand archetypes have been used to brand similar brands? Provide detailed examples for support.

By choosing one or more archetypes and personas at the beginning of our project we can establish characteristics that will continuously evolve and weave their way into all future aspects of the brand. These archetypes and personas can always be referenced back to as a base for the brand and will continue to make sure we stay on target. Having these pieces in place also gives a continued cohesive direction to all elements (logos, video, web, etc.) developed further in the process. Fosters Beer (http://www.fostersbeer.com/#/home) is similar brand both in product and the somewhat tongue in cheek humor that we plan to use in our designs. Fosters uses what appears to be three intertwined archetypes which consist of the jester, explorer and everyman. The jester plays the role of comedian and is found in their tagline that permeates through their entire brand, “Australian for Beer.” They feed off this element to create humors videos that take everyday elements and compare them to how Australians’ “see” those same elements in a much more rugged way. To hold the jester archetype together Fosters uses the explorer to keep the brand feeling like the outback has come to America in a can. All the rugged aspects of Australia are in your can. Then all of these elements are fed through the everyman archetype by portraying the Australian characters as everyday people you would meet. Explorer kicks in; we want to be that guy we just watched get hit with something and brush it off. We can find that connection through drinking the same beer they do and we can laugh about those characters and our comparison to them.

6. What archetypes and personas do you feel are appropriate for the motion and interactive aspects of the brands you are developing for Project #5? Why? Based on what research do you justify these assertions? Provide detailed examples for support.


Referencing the previous question I feel that the everyman, jester and explorer archetypes will be the keys to our brand. We want to establish a base tongue and cheek comedic stereotype of the Colorado weekend warrior and mountain explorer as the bases for who would utilize our product. Portraying our characters as the everyman helps to not limit our demographic to simply mountain goers but also those who wish to identify with a similar lifestyle. Putting our characters in the comedy situations where they must use our beer to survive (even though any beer or beer bottle could be used) makes you laugh that we would propose such tactics. Some research for these choices can be found in the very opinions of out of staters or transplants to Colorado. One interesting source I found was a Colorado gazette based in Colorado Springs. A piece of the article,


“On fitting the Colorado stereotype: "I often wish someone would mentor me on how to be a Coloradan. Take me hunting. Take me fishing. Maybe I'm really missing out," Ginsburg says. "There should be a service for people from the East Coast: orientation."” (full article http://www.gazette.com/articles/don-34773-colorado-hike.html)


Playing on these sorts of ideas we can craft a personality for the brand that jokingly jabs and these associations with Colorado natives and the type of lives and experiences they lead. Our brand then uses our crafted beer as a hilarious solution to the proposed problem of the lifestyle our “drinkers” lead. Like Fosters our explorer elements will tie the activities and location to the brand and the representatives of the brand. http://www.state.co.us/visit_dir/OutdoorRec.html provides a basis for the types of outdoor activities we promote from the state itself. We can then focus our brand with respect to video and interactive aspects to better suit what would be expected activity of Coloradans.

Using other micro-brew companies helps to develop our differentiation and in the end is what really helps to justify the archetypes we will choose. Many of the local companies like to utilize the Colorado outdoors aesthetic and tie that feel to their beers appeal for being closer to that lifestyle (one example http://www.breckbrew.com/). We will capture that same appeal but rather than accentuate that we will in many ways mock what it represents outside of our state. In the end we want those that drink the beer to laugh first, no matter where they are from, at the outrageous situations Coloradans get into while living here.

Critical Questions Set Eight

After reading Preparing for the Meme Wars, Under the Knife and Text Without Context a lot of information about designs connection to the many aspects of our lives is floating around our brains. 5 Key Design Trends makes a strong point to not limit designs and ideas simply to what people want and instead seek to be different and break the rules. In this light does design mimic life (or life mimic design) and as such require us as designers to consider what people want but stay true to our work (personality)? I feel this question is important because we have been told quite frequently to always consider our target demographic in everything we brand. Since branding is part of design how do we also know when we should be breaking the rules?

A topic addressed by Faith Popcorn in the reading is that the future (now the present) of design focusing primarily around simplicity and ease of use. While this is a key component to a modern successful brand will we eventually see a society who becomes bored with over simplicity? This can be important to address because potentially, as a design community, we would want a balance of complexity and simplicity. Complexity entails “smart complexity” that does not lead to frustration and anger but achievement for solving or realizing elements of a design that not everyone may initially understand. A follow up question would be that is it possible to achieve both complex and simple without losing the other elements of the design in a focus around functionality?

Critical Questions Set Seven

While reading through Text Without Context I found myself not only agreeing with the overlaying opinion about digital cultures destruction of its reference media and online personalities but also remember having these very same thoughts fill my head over the past few years. Yet not only am I designer who contributes to the effort but I am part of the digital community who partakes in this online media world. I find myself at a crossroads where I believe there is a middle ground and that Text Without Context just realizes these issues but does not have any solution. While weighing both positives and negatives of each side of this discussion can we as designers possibly solve an issue this large? This proposed question is broad and will vary from person to person. We sit at the crossroads of this issue where we appeal to the ever evolving masses while still holding to knowledge of the past and every decision we make in our work has a reason. The importance of this question might currently lie in just answering it but to simply begin thinking about it for it is far too early to formulate one right answer (if there is one).

Text Without Context persistently proposes that the web continues to create simplicity of everyday or traditional social (in person) interactions and in doing so losses the value and context within. Designers develop within this media and often seek to create simplicity to fill an expected desire our consumers generally look for while surfing. Un-focusing on the smaller aspect of current social demands within web media leads us to a more important question. Are designers the ones who mold culture and social environments (predominantly on the web) or are we merely just another cog in a collective process? While knowing our role (if it can be defined so easily) might help us to craft better designs it can also hamper what we believe ourselves to be capable of. It is simply important to discuss this topic so we can consider deeper meanings about the personal values we interject into our work and if our efforts even matter in the grand scheme.

Critical Questions Set Six

After reading Preparing for the Meme Wars I found myself thinking about where I have heard the term meme recently. The internet has manifested into a common ground for memes and in many ways they have become part of its recent subculture. A prevalent example of this is the famous “Rick Roll” where someone you know (or in some cases don’t know) will post a link to a video that actually turns out to be a video of an 80’s song by Rick Ashley. This raises the question to whether design has “infected” our culture to not only respond to memes but to begin crafting them for self entertainment. This is important to distinguish because we as designers must take every factor into account when crafting a brand. If we are in a culture that crafts their own memes simply for entertainment can we work into this asset or does it come off as advertising simply corrupting another piece of our everyday lives. In many ways this also relates to some of the issues addressed in Under the Knife about advertising leading to instant skepticism.

In Under the Knife the author (when they wrote this) seems to mentally lump design with advertising. In my opinion with all the areas that design inhabits it has become more important than ever that designers seek something more than just the sale and being ever present and in your face. Design seems to be the most effective when you don’t even realize something has been designed and it just feels right. It leaves me with the question; does the consumer market simply see design at face value because of bad design or does good design still have a clairvoyant image in their minds? I feel the importance of this question is simply to justify spending time not only looking at good design but bad design and how it influences the public.